BuddhaJones.org Archive Project

Free Nichiren Buddhism

← Archive Index Message Board
Jul 30, 2008 · BuddhaJones Message Board

A Group That Serves You Versus One That Serves Itself

BuddhismPoliticsIndependent

Are you a member of a group that supports your spiritual development and, in Buddhist terms, your movement toward liberation? Or does the group stunt your spiritual growth? Here's a quick comparison to help you tell the difference between a group that holds you down and a group that helps you soar.
A group that respects your individual autonomy lifts you up.

A group that expects or enforces compliance holds you down.

A vibrant group tolerates and even encourages questions and independent, critical thinking.

A spiritless group discourages questions and independent, critical thinking.

A healthy group encourages psycho-spiritual integration.

An unhealthy group "splits" members into a "good self" which lives up to group ideals and the "bad self" which must be overcome or eradicated.

Conversion to a genuine spiritual path involves an unfolding of internal processes central to your individual identity.

Conversion to a cult of personality involves surrender to an external authority or leader who knows little about and cares little for your individual identity.

A constructive group tries to help individuals meet their spiritual needs by providing opportunities for fellowship and study.

A destructive group exploits spiritual needs to make members increasingly dependent on the group for fellowship and study.

Ethical groups view money as a means -- subject to accountability and transparency -- toward achieving noble ends.

Unethical groups view money as an end or as a means toward achieving power, influence or the goals of the leader, with little or no concern for accountability and transparency.

Ethical groups respond to critics respectfully.

Unethical groups frequently intimidate critics with threats of legal action or "voodoo" threats -- such as, "If you criticize us, you will be punished by supernatural forces."

Ethical groups encourage a person to think carefully before making a commitment to join. They encourage prospective members to look up more information about the group online.

Unethical groups encourage quick decisions with little information. They fear online criticism of the group and preemptively tell prospective members to mistrust information from "unapproved" sources.

(As part of a series I plan to write about Spiritual Self-Defense, I adapted this comparison from "Guidelines for Clergy" by Rev. Richard L. Dowhower, which appears in the book Recovery From Cults, edited by Michael D. Langone, Ph.D.)

9 comments

mroaks

Reports are circulating about some bad Bowling Club behavior in West Hollywood. This report was posted online, but I'm wondering if anyone out there has first-hand knowledge of the incident. Is it true?

Two Sundays ago, we had our 2009 kick off meeting in West Hollywood.Between 4 and 6AM, someone snuck around and filled al the temple exterior locks with glue. Then, a stack of World Tribunes was left at the doorstep of the chief priest's private gated apartment.Then as he was leaving for the temple, 4 SGI, waiting in a car, leaped out and accosted him verbally about how he slandered President Ikeda.As the meeting started, a group of about 20 SGI in red t-shirts saying SGIUSA assembled at a small dirt covered traffic triangle at the corner. They had video cameras and were acting under the guise of "trash pickup to  help clean the city". 20 SGI for about 100 square feet of dirt.They spent the entire duration of our general meeting there, trying to have "dialogue" with our members. Positioning themselves there, they would get people crossing the street. I went down the street just to seeit for myself.We also recorded someone with a laptop and camera with a telephoto lense sitting in car.Pretty unbelievable.
If this is true, the group in question is more than simply "unhealthy" or "unethical," Auntie. I'd say they're totally unhinged.
habile

This may be an example of why the bowling club is having so many problems playing nice with other sports fans!They have lost their marbles!

mroaks

Robin related more details here:

The activity included taunting the Chief Priest at hias lodging, and harassing members as they crossed the street, taking photos of them, and so on.
Dharmaseeker64 responded:
This incident as described by Robin was "Reported back to the members" during our last district meeting by the central figure with apparent pride.According to the report, national level youth leaders were on deck. While scant cheers were heard amongst the youth upon hearing this incident, all adults were silent.Personally I was appalled upon hearing the incident. Several members also came up to me and wanted to talk about this in private. And I had to have a long talk with my son.
I feel sad and a little afraid for the club members who feel powerless to stop this juvenile thuggery, especially since it's obviously celebrated by the club's leadership.And no wonder the Western Buddhist community at large thinks Nichiren Buddhists are a bunch of crazies.
Cultmember

Maybe Nichiren Shoshu could use some of that spiritual defense  Armchair talks about.

Cultmember

I find it more than a little sad the adults were silent. Did no one protest?  

robin

There were evidently two similar incidents. One was in DC on July 13, confirmed by ds. The other was in LA, on July 20th, reported by Kurt. There was also a weird but unrelated incident in Houston, reported by Jon Petry.  

habile

Please verify facts and information!Taking hearsay and building upon it is like building a house on wet sand.

habile

What? You expect people to speak up and be eaten by the Ravenous Bugblatter Beast of Traal.. er.. I mean the Young Men's Division.When that much Testosterone meats with lunacy rapped up in a supposed Ideology it is best to stay "Shtum"!Wait until the rabble is not together and then deal with the YND's individually. It is best if their mother's take them in hand and march them to the door or the person offended - by the ear if required - so that they can apologize and have a "nip tuck" to the ego at the same time! They should then be grounded and not allowed to play with the other children until they promise to be nice!If they act like children they can be treated like children - and they should be stopped eating candy - they evidently can't handle the sugar or the hormones!

robin

Kurt, Jon, Donna, ds

← My House Is Messy But… Archive Index Theoretical… →

About This Project

BuddhaJones.org Archive Project seeks to collect and preserve information related to Nichiren Buddhism in America. All copyrighted content is presented here without permission under Fair Use guidelines, explicitly for the purposes of research, teaching, criticism, comment, and news reporting. This is a nonprofit, educational site unaffiliated with any religious organization or corporation.